We're collecting stories and memories of Prof. Christian R. H. Raetz's impact on his trainees and colleagues. Please comment to this post to share with others the impact Chris had on your life and career. When commenting, please your name and your connection with the Raetz Lab.
I worked with Chris at Duke from 2004-2010, as a postdoc, and ultimately a senior research associate.
ReplyDeleteI hardly experienced the best Raetz stories,as we found out during the annual lab happy hours, but I certainly witnessed some classic Raetz moments.
One day while Chris was still Chair of the Duke Biochemistry Department, I recall hearing the Geiger counter screaming from the "hot room" for far too long. I poked my head out of the office and saw Mike surveying a certain graduate student after she discovered she was contaminated - all over. Eventually, it came out that the graduate student had been in Chris’s office – while radioactive. By this time, she was not dressed suitably to walk down the hall, and no one else would volunteer to go survey Chris and his office, so I had to. I walked with the clicking Geiger counter down the long hallway to the Chair's office. He was not contaminated, though a bit peeved that the "hot" prep was delayed, but mostly amused by the whole situation. This attitude was borne out a few years later when Chris had a PET scan and came back into lab screeching hot without telling anyone. He got a real kick of having each new person survey him without knowing what was happening. Once again, I heard the Geiger counter screaming and was even more shocked to see someone surveying Chris. As radiation safety officer for the lab, when I pointed out that he wasn't allowed in lab because it violated our permit, he ignored me, of course.
Chris had no patience for rules & bureaucracy. It was often hard not to laugh at his rants over these things which he rightly felt took away from his science. I recall one particular time when we discovered that the lab had never gotten certified for BSL-2 organisms, despite a whole grant to study them. While we were trying to figure out what the bureaucrats needed from us, Chris got exasperated by the whole thing. I was sitting in his office when he said, “Well, maybe I should just autoclave the whole grant.” I couldn’t help but laugh. I thought that was a great way to induce the bureaucrats to help us. He was not joking. We did not autoclave the project, but it was always clear that Chris wanted only to be left to his science, and damn the bureaucracy!
Chris had another PET scan on the same day I was leaving Duke for Novartis in 2010. We went into his snazzy corner office (with a view of the dumpster, as he always pointed out) and chatted. He was extremely radioactive and wanted to keep his distance to limit my exposure, perhaps a good excuse for someone who wasn’t overly affectionate. As it was the last time I saw him in person, I am glad I ignored the damn rules and gave him a big hug.
As a final thought, Chris might now be lamenting the fact that he is no longer eligible for the Nobel prize, but we all know that his only scientific regrets are that he won’t see his final graduate students through to their Ph.D. defenses and publications in person. However, I know he will be there in their heads each time they are doing an experiment and presenting their data because he's still in my head.
I was a graduate student in Chris' lab from 1998-2003. He struck a marvelous balance between making sure we made progress and giving us enough freedom to explore new ideas and techniques, giving us just enough rope to begin to hang ourselves, then making sure that he pulled you back from the abyss before actually going over the edge.
ReplyDeleteI had been trying to develop/adapt a new technique for profiling lipid A from Salmonella grown inside macrophages, an experiment that involved bringing together infection models from another laboratory, an extraction and TLC profiling method developed by Zhimin Zhou and others, and a not inconsiderable amount of radioactivity. I had been banging on this for several months, when he pulled me aside after lab meeting (I still marvel at his ability to keep in his head the details of everyone's project and desperately strive to emulate that myself...not nearly as successfully) and asked me "Are you sure you want to be working on this?"
It was just the blunt encouragement I needed at the time to prod me into stepping back and really troubleshooting the experiment. Not six weeks had elapsed after that point that the system was working again, and it eventually developed into a good story.
Another good Raetz lab story that illustrates his patience and drive to get the science done occurred about 4 years into my graduate career. One of my fellow graduate students had been running the ultracentrifuge when the rotor came off the spindle. Fortunately it was not running at full speed, but the rotor was ruined. When Chris came into the lab, we told him and for a brief second you could see his hackles rising. He said nothing, took a deep breath, and then said, "Well, that isn't much compared to some of the things I destroyed when I was a grad student." Then he told of flooding his laboratory with bacterial growth medium from what I presume was a large fermenter. Maybe some of his colleagues from Kennedy's lab might want to fill in some blanks for the community here...
Chris Raetz will always be a part of who I am as a scientist and as a PI. His exemplary leadership of his laboratory over these many years is an inspiration. As long as I remain in science, Chris will inform everything I do, everything I write, and the manner in which I approach scientific problems.
Although I did not correspond as regularly with Chris as others, and I regret this deeply now, I always will feel as if he is looking over my work, waiting to talk science.
I joined Chris’s lab as a graduate student in 2009, and although I only worked with him for two quick years, it was more than enough time for Chris to teach me the most important lesson every young scientist must learn.
ReplyDeleteTo be honest, when I first came to Duke, I quickly shied away from wanting to rotate in the Raetz Lab. I heard both musings and rumors of the lab-as-meat-grinder, illustrated best by horror stories from the ever-feared Monday Morning Lab Meeting (MMLM). By February of my first year, however, I found Chris’s research the most interesting of the faculty I had considered at Duke, so I began the journey that I continue today in his lab.
The ever-feared MMLM was actually the place where I’ve learned the most as a scientist thus far. It’s not the fine details of these meetings that matter most, as there are other ways I could have learned the dozen or so mechanisms, pathways, and techniques I encountered for the first time each Monday. The real important part of the ever-feared MMLM was learning the primacy of data.
As a fresh graduate student, it was easy to go into these meetings scared and shy about my lack of positive results. After a few of those rough patches that every graduate student hits at some point in their project, I learned that there were two easy steps to successfully survive the ever-feared MMLM.
You simply had to know exactly what you tried, and be able to convey it clearly. Maybe it was just that Chris had tempered himself after thirty years of supervising young scientists, but it wasn’t failure that Chris hated. Chris knew that, sometimes, the right approach will not work without optimization or a better understanding of the system. There’s not way to troubleshoot your experiment, though, if you don’t know what didn’t work.
That’s it, what I’ll call Raetz’s first rule:
Know your data and present it in a way that everyone else in the room knows it too.
Although I’m young, at this point I can easily identify this lesson as the most important thing I’ve learned so far in science. At the end of the day, scientists have a simple goal. Just like the detective in one of those police procedural TV shows, we’re after one thing-- the truth. As scientists, we formulate questions and then we seek out answers. Data is the currency of science. Data is the only way we can answer our questions about the world around us.
It’s a seemingly obvious proposition, but it takes a while to fully grasp. It’s one of those ideas that you think you understand, until you understand. It’s the most important thing I’ve learned so far at Duke.
I joined Chris' lab in May 2007 as a postdoc and am still in the lab. When I came to Duke for my interview he was healthy and still chairman of department. He was extremely sharp and logical. As I joined the lab, I heard that he was seriously considering moving to Boulder. After that we had to face his cancer. During last 3 and half years, the time I shared with him gave me valuable perspective on not only how to approach scientific questions but also how to face life itself. Madeline and Chris always said to me "We cannot complain about the parts of life that we cannot control and just have to do what we have to do". They have always been a solid rock to hold us in the right place.
ReplyDeleteI had an invaluable chance to see how scientists have to focus on science alone. After his first surgery in 2007 I remembered that Chris replied to an e-mail just 2 days later about scientific questions. He was genuinely curious and really enjoyed every piece of data.
He was great mentor in science and in life to me. It was a great blessing to have these past 4 years with him. He will be always in my heart. It is still hard to beleive that he will not reply to e-mails within 5 minutes. However, maybe he will show up in our dreams to discuss the data.
I started to work with Chris in the beginning of 2004. I was hired into his group as a participant of the Lipid Maps consortium which has a strong emphasis on mass spectrometry. I still vividly remember my interview trip to Duke, when I first met him at the Washington Duke Inn for dinner. We talked a lot about Merck, where I was a research scientist at the time, and where he spent six years during 1987-1992. He also mentioned one of his reasons to do research was that he likes to solve puzzles. Later, it turned out a mass spectrometer is a great machine to generate puzzles.
ReplyDeleteEvery time he came to the MS lab, we would often sit in front of a computer, looking at the MS data, either trying to identify a known species, or to piece up a novel lipid structure from MS/MS spectra. Those times became our ‘puzzle times’. He often did this at home by himself using his small Dell laptop PC dedicated to the MS use (while drinking wine or beer as I heard from him). At one point, he was worried that too much time spent on the MS data might ruin his career. (It reminded me of the common worry of addictions to computer games.)
For the Lipid Maps project, he was always appreciative of and even fascinated by the power of modern mass spectrometry in lipid analysis, especially his favorite lipid A, which had made my life a lot easier.
While on the subject of mass spectrometry, I have to mention a couple of molecular weights of lipid A-related molecules that have forever etched in my memory, along with the ‘lessons’ from Chris.
2000 Da:
This is the molecular weight of an unknown component (XWK4) in one of Xiaoyuan Wang’s sample (lpxF mutant of Francisella novicida). I was spending hours trying to figure out the structure based on only the MS/MS data, but without success. It was not surprising or disappointing to me, since this unknown molecule is pretty large, and the fragment ions are not very informative. What impressed me was that it only took Chris about 5 minutes to come up with a structure that was eventually published in PNAS (2007). This lipid A has a 4′-phosphate moiety and a 3′-O-acyl chain.
I won’t go into the details here, but I learned a lesson from him: biochemical insights are complementary, and may even be essential to the MS characterization of a novel lipid structure.
711 Da:
a) It is the molecular weight of lipid X —a famous intermediate in the lipid A pathway, and a molecule that was crucial to Chris’ career—for which had mentioned many times.
b) 7-Eleven is also the name of a convenience store, which means…
c) 7 days a week, 11 hours a day—I think he spent at least that amount of time working on or thinking about science.
Chris’ love and passion for science could only be rivaled by his dedication to his trainees. He will be deeply missed.
I joined the Raetz Lab as a graduate student in May of 2009.
ReplyDeleteDue to circumstances that I will not go into here, I found myself in April of my first year after four rotations (only three are required by the department before joining a lab) without a lab and questioning my future in the department, Duke, and/or science altogether. Not being very familiar with the lipid world, and maybe a little bit afraid of it, I hadn’t considered the Raetz Lab, but as it became clear that my fourth rotation wasn’t working out, Chris graciously allowed me to rotate even though he already had three other students from my class in the lab. I’m still not sure to this day if he did this out of a sense of responsibility to the department or his belief that no student should be forced into a bad solution, but I am eternally grateful for the opportunity. About a month after I began my rotation, we bumped into each other in the Nan Duke hallway and after discussing some data Chris gave me a sideways glance over his glasses and told me as if it was an afterthought that it would be alright with him if I became a permanent member of the lab and promptly returned to his office. The nonchalant manner by which he conveyed such important information caught me off-guard and I don’t think my face expressed the same amount of joy and relief that I felt inside.
One trait of all great scientists is skepticism, and Chris was a master skeptic. I experienced this in my own project first hand as I had to continually prove to Chris that LpxK had actually been crystallized. When the right condition from the initial sparse matrix screens produced beautiful bipyramidal crystals that diffracted, I remember taking my results proudly to Chris’s office. He was delighted, but only for a moment after which he told me to set the condition again and see if the result repeated. After I scaled up the drop to obtain huge ½ mm crystals Chris had me dissolve them in SDS and run them on a gel next to the purified LpxK. Of course they looked identical but Chris wasn’t satisfied. It was only after cutting out the bands and sequencing the protein by mass spec both locally with Dr. Guan and with the Duke proteomics facility that he was truly convinced. This and other experiences with Chris and data have engraved in my mind the centrality of controls to any experiment, and I will always remember how questions at data meeting usually started with “now which lanes are the controls”. God help you if you didn’t have an answer.
Despite being largely home-bound over this past summer, Chris’s mind remained in lab. We came to expect daily phone calls inquiring about any new developments in the work of whoever happened to pick up the phone. As usual, any attempt to change topic to something other than science was quickly thwarted and replaced by new inquiries about data (I really can’t recall doing this successfully more than a handful of times). We received prompt responses to weekly emails that Chris requested outlining what we had presented at data meeting that Monday. Aside from being physically able to view every piece of data, Chris was as much a part of lab as he ever had been, as if his life-force and ability to think and do science were somehow intimately connected.
Finally, I want to share my thoughts about my view of Chris’s lasting legacy. Chris throughout his career put the quality of his science and welfare of his students above all else. He took his role as a mentor extremely seriously, and it is because of that fact that all of us over the years are and will be willing to work hard and strive for excellence in our own science both at Duke and abroad. Chris had big dreams for all of his students, and I know that I will strive for what he envisioned throughout my career. Though I will never measure up to his brilliance, I only hope not to be counted among the “bozos”. That is the least I can do for such a stalwart mentor and friend. Chris, you will be missed.
I was a student with Chris from 2004-2008. Though I was officially split between Chris and Pei Zhou, I was made to feel as though I were a full time member of both labs, with all the inherent advantages and liabilities of such an arrangement.
ReplyDeleteThe other posters have done a wonderful job of hitting some of Chris's highlights. There is no doubt the most important thing I learned from Chris, as a direct result of the Monday meetings, was how to quickly, thoroughly and clearly present my results. Chris provided instant feedback when one wandered away from this ideal, either by immediately questioning the aspects that didn't make sense or becoming eerily quiet as his attention faded towards other aspects of lipid biochemistry.
It quickly became obvious to me that Chris made substantial contributions to the careers of his students in addition to providing the opportunity for a rigorous education in science. Many collaborations and interviews have begun with "So you were a student with Chris Raetz!" This exposure has opened up numerous opportunities for those of us who were fortunate enough to work under his supervision.
I will always be grateful to Chris for never discouraging me from attempting an experiment. While he may have thought some of my experiments were not the best use of my time, I was allowed the freedom to learn for myself.
On the lighter side, one Monday morning Chris, Guan and Teresa were discussing a MS experiment to measure lipid levels in mouse neural tissue. The conversation went something like this:
Teresa-well, the preliminary experiment was OK but I think we can do better
Chris- was the tissue fresh?
Guan- no it had been frozen and thawed a few times
Chris- oh, well then I think we should use fresh brains
Teresa- Yes, fresh brains would be better
Guan- yes, fresh brains
Teresa- I'll get a hold of some fresh brains.
Chris- good. definitely use fresh brains
The humor, perhaps momentarily lost on these three, was not lost on Louis and I that morning as we looked across the table at each other and struggled to maintain decorum.
Along with David, as mentioned above, I will always remember Chris coming to the lab after his first PET scan and asking me to place the Geiger counter near his forehead. No doubt about it, as a scientist, mentor and patient, he was hot.
I joined the Raetz lab just in November 2010 as a post-doc.
ReplyDeleteIn the short amount of time that I have known him, I have learned so much from Chris. The MMLM (Monday Morning Lab Meeting, mentioned above by Rob) has been the place where I have gained the most knowledge as a scientist. Knowledge that can't be taught, but must be learned through observation and mentorship. MMLM was the breeding ground for this knowledge for many of us. I will forever be grateful to Chris for placing emphasis on the importance of controls and properly presenting data. I can tell a difference in my own skepticism from the short time I spent in his lab.
It was easy at first to be intimidated by MMLM, working for such a well respected and known to be tough scientist. But after some time, I have come to understand that he is tough on you to make you learn. Monday mornings were always stressful, wondering if I have enough data to present, never wanting to go in 'empty-handed'(i.e only failed experiments). But Chris very well understood that progress does not always mean moving forward, but learning what doesn't work as well. Chris was great at understanding that science takes patience and almost never works the first time. He never let me feel bad for not providing results, only for presenting them inappropriately or missing controls! Although, we all know he was always happier with fresh data ;)
As I continue in my own career, I know that his influence on me will always continue. I'll always think "What would Chris say about this data? What would Chris want to see to believe this data? What else could I do to confirm my data?"
Chris's persistence in pursuing quality data is one of the reasons he is so well respected, and is his living legacy, found in all those who were fortunate enough to call themselves Raetz lab members.
I started working with Chris as a graduate student in September 2008, where I did both my first and third lab rotations with him. As a first year graduate student, I was in his lab so much that everyone assumed I had already joined well before the obligatory three rotation periods were over. I remember, when it came time to make things official, instead of me approaching Chris, Chris pulled me aside and said “You still want to work for me, right?”
ReplyDeleteI work on a project that initially….to be frank, no one knew what the heck was going on. We had these funny, messed up mutants that were really resistant to LpxC inhibitors, and we had no clue why. The two years that followed were frustrating, confusing, and counterintuitive. Through it all, Chris never gave up on the project or me (though we did come up with a backup project, Chris was very good in making sure we never got stuck). He always had suggestions and papers for me to read and never said no to experiments I wanted to try (even when they cost him ten grand). I thoroughly enjoyed and learned so much from our discussions of science.
For the first two years, I always felt rather shy and nervous around Chris, understandably I think, when talking to such a great scientist and brilliant mind. When I finally apologized to him for my demeanor, he simply replied, “Don’t be intimidated by white, bald men in suits.”
Throughout my three years of working with Chris, without fail, every time I started a conversation with him, he would always ask, “How are you doing?” Even in those last weeks when he was in clear discomfort, the first thing he would say is “Hi Daina, this is Chris, how are you doing?” It was only after I finished talking about myself would he tell me how he was feeling. It’s clear how dedicated of a mentor he was.
Personally, had I known back in 2009 that Chris would pass away; I would have still replied back to him two years ago “Yes, of course I want to work for you! Do YOU still want to accept me?” Working for Chris has been one of the greatest honors of my life. I’m a much better scientist and person because of him.
Chris, I’m doing really well. I miss you, and I’ll never forget you. Thank you so much for everything.
While a post-doc in the early 1990's, I read a number of Chris' articles on lipid A. His research had a huge impact on the work I was doing at the time. When I first had the opportunity to meet him in 2007, I was incredibly excited to be able to sit, drink a beer and chat with one of my science idols. It was a moment that I treasure. I was also impressed with the fact that not only was he an outstanding scientist, he was also approachable, friendly and a really nice guy. I was delighted, excited and thrilled to have the opportunity to collaborate and publish with him over the past few years. I will miss him.
ReplyDeleteWhile so much seemingly tough but actually sweet moments have been mentioned by the folks posted prior to me, I'd like to share some moments that happened in my post-Raetz-lab period, particularly his visit of Hong Kong in March 2010.
ReplyDeleteI was extremely delighted that he could make his trip to Hong Kong in the second year of my independent career as an assistant professor. I have accumulated so much questions about this job: grant writing, students, managing a lab, dealing with colleagues from different cultures and background..... that I was desperate to be advised. And there Chris came, at the time I needed a wise mind the most. People have told me how enjoyed Chris was when he visited Asia (me and Xiao), but it was me that benefited the most from his visit. He offered me invaluable advice on those things we'd never imagine to encounter when we were a student or a postdoc. He literally saved me from the burning field of the life of a second year assistant professor. Those words he spoke to me, they still rumble in my mind, and every time I recall, I gain something new, something wiser which keep me moving forward fearlessly.
When he visited me at Hong Kong, I also "dared" to ask him questions outside the realm of science which I would never imagined to have the courage to do during the time I worked with him. To my great delight and surprise, he shared many moments of him being a father and a grandfather with me and I could feel a very tender heart he has to his family. From those conversations, I gained many wise insights into life which I'll treasure for a long time. Because of this experience, I felt I am so privileged to see the non-science side of Chris which is very valuable among the moments he spent with us.
For that and for many other unmentioned wisdom I gained from him, I was, I am, and I will always be proud and honored to be a member of "The Raetz scientific family". From that point of view and from reading all the sweet moments Chris had spent with us from the other members of this "family", it seemed to me that Chris didn't really leave, he just created a chance for everybody in this "scientific family" to get together and to share.
He is a legacy and he will be remembered and missed by me for a long time......
I was a student in the Raetz lab in Madison from 1984-1989. I was also Chris' first coworker in the lab at Duke in 1993 (more on that later).
ReplyDeleteWhen Chris and most of the lab moved to Merck, I stayed in Madison. I really appreciate that Chris trusted me to finish my experiments and write my thesis there, without the down-time of a move. I gained some independence and confidence during that time, and it was fun going to New Jersey once in awhile to show him my data.
I agree with all the above postings indicating that Chris was an outstanding mentor who gave us the liberty and time to explore and learn. One example in my case was when I was trying to scale-up and purify the crude in vitro KDO-transferase product. I had spent a couple of months to no avail, trying various columns, etc. Then Chris went out of town for several days, and that's when I got it. He said, “I guess I should leave town more often.” Then came the structural determination, to see how many KDO residues there were. We had to do 2-D NMR because the regular NMR had too many overlapping signals. He saw me coming down the hall with the print-out. Although I'm sure he wanted to grab it away from me (it would have taken him 30 seconds to understand it), he did not. He let me figure it out since it was my project. It took me FOREVER. Chris waited patiently (well, sort of) for me to tell him that there were 2 KDO's instead of just one. I really appreciated that.
The lesson Chris taught me that I think of most frequently is the importance of data: what do they say, what do they not say. Be logical, be methodical. Be careful not to over-conclude.
Chris was an excellent instructor. His students' learning was important to him, and he took the time to prepare well for his classes. Even when it took time away from his research and other duties. I am now a high school chemistry and biology teacher, and try to keep Chris' example in mind.
The Madison lab members will recall the E. coli van. It was a large bacillus-shaped van that the Raetz's had at the time, with “E. coli” on the license plate. I had the honor of driving said van one time between two Gordon conferences. It had one of those old-fashioned stick shifts (like a tractor), and the 2nd gear did not work. So you had to get going really fast in 1st gear and then throw it directly into 3rd—ouch. Chris was worried that I might not know how to do it so he had me practice. I'm sure we looked ridiculous in the parking lot with that blue bacillus lurching around.
After finishing my Ph.D. in 1989, I did a post-doc and got an industry job that I didn't like very much. So in 1993, I went to Duke to help Chris set up the lab there and get some experiments going. That was a really special time for me, even though it was only for 2 years. I got to do experiments that I was truly interested in. I loved the working environment at Duke, and the beauty of the town. And, I was able to work with Chris as more of a colleague (post-doc) than a student. If I hadn't gotten married and moved away in 1995, Chris would probably have had a hard time getting rid of me.
I had a little old bungalow on Chapel Hill Road with a big backyard, where we had frequent lab parties/barbecues. Chris and Madeline's house had not been built yet. Chris always filled the cooler and manned the barbecue. I have such fond memories of that house and the good times we all shared there.
I will always remember Chris for his unparalleled enthusiasm for science, his thoughtful mentoring, and his friendship. Working with Chris was a great honor for me. He will always be close in my heart and mind, and I will miss him greatly.
I was a Postdoc in Chris’s lab from 1999-2004. While a lot of us can thank Chris for our current careers, I can track my career success back to one particular conversation I had with Chris following a lab meeting in 2002. At that point I had been a postdoc in the Raetz lab for 2+ years. One of my early successes was the isolation of a temperature sensitive mutant with a mutation in the msbA gene, encoding the lipid A/LPS transporter.
ReplyDeleteThis mutant accumulated lipids in the cytoplasmic leaflet of the inner membrane under nonpermissive growth conditions. Chris was extremely excited about this work and he included my data in most of the invited seminars he gave around this time.
I was looking to use this mutant to investigate the then-unknown pathway of LPS transport from the inner bacterial membrane to the outer membrane. To do this I wanted to find a genetic screen that would enrich for msbA mutants and, possibly other LPS transport mutants. After this particular lab meeting, Chris passed me in the hallway and suggested trying Ludox. Ludox is a type of colloidal silica that forms a density gradient during moderate centrifugation and can be used to separate cells according to differences in density. It was used by Novick, Field and Schekman in their famous 1981 Cell paper describing the isolation of the first yeast “sec” mutants based on these mutants increase in density under nonpermissive growth conditions. The idea was that a mutant that accumulated lipids within the cell may experience changes in density that could be exploited in a genetic screen. I never would have thought to try something so strange but since Chris suggested it, I started reading up on the use of Ludox. To make a long story short, we were able to isolate new msbA mutants from a randomly mutagenized population of E. coli cells using this screen, and, in addition, several new unknown mutants were also isolated. Chris let me take this project with me and the procedure became the subject of my first paper as an assistant professor.
One of the new mutants I found led to a series of papers, an NSF grant, tenure, and projects for a number of PhD students in my current lab at LSU. So not only did Chris provide excellent training and a great postdoc experience, he also planted the idea that sprouted into what became the focus of my entire lab and possibly my entire career. Chris was an endless source of ideas and I was fortunate to know him. I try to emulate him every day especially when dealing with young students. He was my hero, and I will miss him dearly.
I graduated from the Raetz Laboratory in 2010. Chris coupled an extraordinarily broad view of science with an appreciation for practical detail. To him, research was an art of the possible; Chris had an unerring sense of what might reasonably be accomplished to make incremental progress in any given project. His emphasis upon publishing detailed, reproducible methods harks from an era when reporting well-vetted experiments was considered to be of greater importance than today’s scramble for impact scores. Chris was never inspired by self-aggrandizement, but rather by an irresistible and innate curiosity that animated him even in his final weeks. He had no preconceived notions, no scientific biases: he simply wanted to know how his corner of science worked. His open-minded approach, his desire to embrace new techniques, and his generosity with collaborators and colleagues made him a grand seigneur of biochemical research. We are all poorer for his loss.
ReplyDeleteChris Raetz was a talented manager. An under-appreciated difficulty of running a research program is striking a balance between micromanagement and disengagement. Many primary investigators inhabit one or the other of these extremes; Chris did an admirable job of finding a balance that worked for his trainees. He kept long hours, and he expected the same from his colleagues. He expressed heartfelt joy when each of us made progress in our research. He was formidable, yet approachable. He motivated us when we needed it, and he gave us hope at difficult junctures. He was unstinting in his support of his former students and postdoctoral scholars. The phone calls wherein he relayed the lab’s recent findings were often the highlight of my week. Whether consciously or as a natural byproduct of his approach to research, Chris taught all of us a great deal about prioritization, management, and perseverance through the tragedies and the triumphs of scientific exploration.
I have many stories about Chris, and I will post more of them in the coming days. I emphasize that Chris Raetz was a serious man with a serious purpose, but that he also possessed a lighter, personable, "qualitative" side to balance his analytical talents.
One of my best memories of Chris was when he took Craig Bartling and me to a Gordon Conference. Traveling to New Hampshire via Boston, we were taken by Chris to dinner with Harvard’s Professor Eugene Kennedy. It was interesting to see our mentor (Chris) in the presence of his mentor (Kennedy), and to hear some of the stories from the discovery of the glycerophospholipid biosynthetic enzymes. On our return from the conference, Chris insisted that Craig and me (we grew up in Ohio and Arizona/New Mexico, respectively) enjoy a proper lunch of New England steamed clams. He provided us with extraordinarily precise, semi-quantitative instructions on how to correctly eat the clams, as was his wont.
A memorable discussion once arose at a lab meeting regarding the "true" temperature of water boiling in the lab's rusty/corroded water bath. After much discussion, we concluded that dissolved solutes in the bath were affecting the boiling temperature, or that the thermometer was somehow poorly calibrated. The "temperature of boiling water" lab meeting became something of a laboratory classic, and, unknown to Chris, the subject of ongoing lab humor. A few years later, on Christmas Eve, Chris, Madeline, and Lizzy Raetz invited Hak Suk Chung and me to dinner. Goose was on the menu, and Madeline used a digital meat thermometer to monitor the progress of the experiment. Chris, characteristically, wondered aloud whether the thermometer was properly calibrated, which in turn caused him to remember the infamous water bath discussion, and to ask if that (long-ago) problem had been fixed.
ReplyDeleteIn his earlier post, David Six mentions that he still hears Chris providing running commentary during experiments. I can confirm that the mental replay of certain stock “Chris Raetz scientific phrases” is a common experience of "Raetz Lab Survivors." Some of Raetz's favorite (and helpful) thoughts:
"Did you add piperidine to that?”
“Where's the vector control?”
“There's something fishy/chequered about that prep.”
For special occasions, Chris would host a happy hour in his office to celebrate lab milestones. He would usually ask someone to accompany him on a shopping trip to the seedy Kroger store near Duke’s campus. Oblivious to the boisterous hordes of Duke fraternity members stocking up with Keystone Light for their Friday night benders, Chris ambled incongruously amidst chaos, impeccably dressed, holding forth on his latest thoughts about various projects. He paid attention to the mundane world, but a large part of his consciousness frolicked amid chemical structures, mass spectra, and autoradiographs, always turning pieces of the endless puzzle about in his mind’s eye. That passion, that laser focus, was an element of his greatness and the source of his strength. Chris belongs to the ages now, but he leaves a spectacular legacy to a world for which he held an insatiable, infectious curiosity.
I went to work for Chris in my sophomore year as a Duke undergraduate, the fall of 2000. I had emailed a number of faculty members across various departments, looking for someone who would be willing to take a student. Chris was one of the few who replied, inviting me to come and see him. As a sophomore who had only just gotten to move up to the big West Campus from the kindergarten that is East Campus, I felt a great degree of trepidation walking into a research building and on into the department chair’s office. In that first meeting, I was amazed at Chris’ openness, and at how he treated me as if I were a fellow scientist, a colleague worthy of respect. I knew almost nothing, and I’m sure Chris was completely aware of that – he was probably winking to the next postdoc who came in the office – but that respect and trust had a profound impact on me. For a sophomore coming from a small town, from a family with no academics or scientists, from schools that were far from first-rate, being one among hundreds of undergrads slogging it out in organic chemistry and the like, to be taken seriously by someone like Chris was an extraordinary gesture. It was no less extraordinary when Chris did exactly as he promised, turning me loose to work on a project of my own, treating me in many ways the same as his graduate students and postdocs, providing just the right amount of guidance but always letting me take the lead. It would be hard to underestimate what those three years with Chris did for my confidence and independence.
ReplyDeleteLike everyone else who has commented here, I came away from my time in the Raetz Lab with a deep appreciation for the importance of data. I also came away with a deep appreciation for reason, argument, and analysis. I had never seen anything like Monday Morning Lab Meeting: a group of brilliant people having a completely open, completely freewheeling debate. Someone would show a piece of data, and the ideas and explanations would start flying. Sitting in on those meetings (I cannot claim to have contributed!) was an education in how to think, as well as a demonstration of what is possible when a group of smart people work together from a standpoint of equality and mutual respect.
Working with Chris was probably the most important part of my undergraduate education. My classes taught me factual knowledge; Chris taught me how to think and reason, how to approach problems, how to ask scientific questions and how to find and verify their answers, and what kind of attitude to take towards both success and failure. It was Chris, far more than anyone or anything else at Duke, who developed me into a scientist and intellectual.
(Continued...)
(...continuing)
ReplyDeleteWhy does every story about Chris seem to involve radioactivity? I’ll never forget Chris coming into the hot room one day with his coffee to talk to someone, plopping the mug down on the bench in the middle of some screaming-hot prep someone was running (I want to say that it was one of Sandy’s notorious ones). Someone said, “Chris, you really shouldn’t put that there,” and he didn’t even take notice. He was always coming around to chat. I remember many times as an undergrad when he came up to the desk unexpectedly, asking, “So, how are things going?” It was really a treat, because one never knew where such conversations would go. I learned more about the Duke Administration from Chris’ unexpected visits than I ever would’ve dreamed of. Chris’ visits remained a constant in my life from undergrad all the way through the beginning of this summer, even as I shifted from his lab to Pei Zhou’s and then to my own independence. Having an office right next to his for the last year and a half, I never knew when he would stick his head in to ask how teaching or projects were going. It was always a delight. He could never decide what he thought I should do with myself, which made for some amusing discussions about careers, especially as my own plans were evolving – but through all of it there was no one more supportive. We weren’t as close after I took a turn into NMR methodology, but he seemed very pleased when I later wound up taking over for Teresa in teaching basic biochemistry to the undergraduates. He was continually curious about the state of that class these last few years, and he was always ready with advice. It was fun to have him teach a few guest lectures last fall on some of his favorite topics. I only wish that he could have been around a little this summer, so that I could have showed him some of the data coming out of my first completely independent project.
Our relationship changed some as we went from the undergraduate and his advisor, to the graduate student and his committee member, to the beginning teacher and his far more experienced sounding board, to the new faculty member getting lots of advice from the faculty member who has seen it all – but the essentials remained the same throughout. Chris was a colleague, a mentor, and a friend. He will be sorely missed, but his memory will indeed live on, in his substantial contributions to science, in the achievements of the many students he trained, and in the approaches that we new teachers and mentors are passing along now to the next generation of scientists.
I worked with Chris from 1993-1997. I was the first student to join and graduate from the lab at Duke. I was number 11 overall.
ReplyDeleteI am the first person from my family to get an advanced degree, and in hindsight, I realize that when I arrived at Duke I was bumbling around without a clue what I’d gotten myself into. Somehow I managed to land on my feet, but I think my sheer luck in joining the Raetz lab has been a big contributor to my successes. Chris was an amazing mentor, and his dedication to the professional development of all his trainees was unsurpassed. He was an inspiring model for how to be successful at tackling challenging questions—sometimes persistently chipping away at them little by little, sometimes through big creative breakthroughs, often by making connections using the vast amounts of data/knowledge he could somehow unfailingly remember. He was generally good at gauging the amount of mentoring I needed—striking a good balance so that I was neither “micromanaged” nor left to flounder for too long doing secret, unsanctioned experiments.
All of this made it incredibly fun to be in the Raetz lab during my time there—from the very beginning when Kathy and Chris constituted the entire lab, to my departure from a large and vibrant group. The science was always top notch, but there were so many good stories outside of the lab work too. It was clear from the first time I met him, that Chris rarely took a break from thinking about science, often leaving other areas of life to take care of themselves. Particularly before Madeline moved from Rahway to NC, we tried to help him out when we could. He tolerated our good-natured teasing about this with forbearance. I guess when you’re an accomplished scientist, people will cut you some slack if you don’t know how to use an ATM. I think the impromptu cookouts at Kathy’s house prevented him from eating at Papagayo for dinner every night (if he remembered to eat dinner at all). We taught him to make coffee and use the photocopier on a Monday holiday that we (of course) still had lab meeting, but Brenda, Linda and Esther were not there. We teased him because he had a colony blot and matching autoradiogram in his wallet, but no photos of Jackie and Lizzie (to his credit, he did have framed photos of them in his office). Chris found it ironic that he helped to develop Proscar at Merck, when it was later approved to treat male-pattern baldness. He often fretted about looking bald in photographs, but I think the entire lab felt some measure of triumph when he got rid of his signature comb-over before his daughter Jackie started medical school at Duke. The stories go on and on. . .
I last spoke to Chris at length after I found out my first R01 had been funded. He was the first person I called after I got the news. Even after all the intervening years, his approval was important to me, and it felt good to make him proud. I will miss him more than I can say, and it heartens me to know that the extended Raetz lab family will carry on his legacy.
I interviewed with Chris to become a post-doc in his lab on the same day Bill Clinton was re-elected for his second term. The large majority of lab members at that time were women, which I was told could be attributed to Kathryn Brozek, who had positively influenced grad student recruiting when Chris was setting up his lab at Duke. Chris warned me that I had to win approval from his existing contingent of trainees before I could ever be recruited to his lab as a post doc. Fortunately, I was later informed that I could join the lab if I could manage to secure a fellowship. In the Spring of 1998, I arrived at the lab newly married with a 4 month old daughter, a newly minted PhD in biochemistry from the University of Alberta, and with support from the Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research. Chris' first act of generosity toward me was to pay the bill of moving my belongings over the 4000 km journey from Edmonton to Durham. I could never have afforded to pay that cost myself.
ReplyDeleteI didn't know anything about Chris except that I liked the papers he was publishing (mostly in JBC) as I was gearing up to write my PhD thesis. The papers indicated he worked at Merck labs and I was not interested in doing an industrial post doc, but Dennis Vance had posted a letter from Chris indicating that he was recruiting for a new lab at Duke. Chris' letter was more than a year old, but I sent him my CV anyway. The project I eventually inherited was forged previously by the work of Masahiro Nishijima, and later, by Kathryn Brozek. It soon became obvious to me that Chris' lab was a special place. Everybody's particular enzyme required that they knew how to prepare its substrate, but the product of that enzyme would be the substrate for the next person's enzyme - so everybody depended on the success of everyone else. Chris oversaw all this at Monday morning group meeting, which started at 8:30AM and usually ended around 11AM with Chris having reviewed everybody's notes from the previous week. He would notice little things, like an apparent contaminant in a TLC plate that he recalled having seen before 6 months ago and wondered if it was really a contaminant or something more important. His memory was incredible.
Chris' lab was like a tightly run ship, but I am still today amazed by the amount of commitment required from him to make that a reality. He was always around to keep track of the pulse in the lab. For a department Chairman, Chris was visible in the lab far more than I imagined he would be. I assumed he must work extensively after hours to do all the other things he had to do, but the one time I stayed at his house we (he and Madeline and I) watched an episode of Seinfeld together and all retired for the evening at a reasonable time. It soon became clear to me that Chris Raetz had to have some special gifts to be able to do all the things he was constantly doing. If only I could ever be that organized!
I will always remember Chris for his generosity, but I should also mention something about his child-like enthusiasm for the process of discovery. He had just uncovered in a Blast search that some of the enzymes of lipid A biosynthesis appeared to be conserved in plants. Charlie Sweet had pulled out the old mortar and pestle and was grinding up Arabidopsis extracts to screen for various enzymes, but the experiments seemed a bit beyond the expertise of this bunch of E. coli aficionados. Then, I walked into Chris' office after he had just gotten off the phone and he informed me that a core facility in Wisconsin could make targeted mutants in Arabidopsis for a nominal fee. Chris was literally jumping for joy. I will never forget his excitement at that moment. Chris genuinely loved discovery and he genuinely cared when experiments didn't work. He seemed ever present in the lab because he really cared to know what was going on. I remind myself of this aspect of Chris' character when I sometimes feel tempted to complain about the goings on in my own lab.
(... continued)
ReplyDeleteWhen I was looking for faculty positions, Chris encouraged me to take my PagP project with me. I was recruited to the University of Toronto in 2000. Since Chris had a vested interest in my work, I wasn't surprised when he invited himself for a visit. He said, I have to go to California for an Annual Reviews of Biochemistry meeting and they don't care which route I take on the way back. I think he genuinely wanted to find out if I had been given all the resources I needed to be successful. Chris gave a dynamite seminar outlining Bill Doerrler's recent results with MsbA mutants and proceeded to meet my colleagues. I arranged for Chris to meet Lewis Kay and Chris soon convinced Lewis that he and I should start collaborating on PagP. The outcome of that collaboration had a lot to do with me being awarded tenure in 2005.
I soon learned that I wasn't the only Raetz survivor to benefit from Chris' influence after they had left the Raetz lab. His phone calls were consistent - about every 4-6 months - for the 11 years after I left his lab. I'm certain that I was invited to speak at several prestigious meetings because Chris had suggested my name. I'm probably on the editorial board of the JBC for the same reason. These may seem like small things to Chris, but they made a big difference in my career. Bill Dowhan once nominated Chris for the William C. Rose award because of his demonstrated commitment to the mentoring of younger scientists. It's too bad Chris didn't win that award, but I believe he certainly deserved it.
After I was recruited to McMaster University in 2006, I invited Chris up for a seminar to save him the trouble of having to invite himself. My students had heard so much about Chris Raetz and they were all excited to meet him. Not long before, I had driven my eldest daughter (then 8) to reconnect with the Raetz Survivors in Worcester for Chris' fictitious Danforth lecture (really just an excuse to surprise Chris for his 60th birthday). You have to be pretty special to have your trainees do something like that for you. Chris’ visit to McMaster was the last time I saw him before he informed me that he had to have his thyroid removed. I was so relieved to learn that he was still working and in remission. Last October, Chris invited me to give a talk at Duke - 10 years after I had left (and my first time back). He was doing great. The last time we talked he asked me to provide a review for a manuscript on lipid A in plants that he was submitting to PNAS (his latest paper in fact). He mentioned he was planning to stay at Bill Dowhan's place in Houston to undergo a procedure that, in his words, probably wouldn't work. It didn't sound ominous to me at the time, but I was worried by his insistence that I should be identified as a potential supervisor for some of his trainees as a part of his so-called contingency plan. On Thursday August 11, I felt the compulsion to send Chris an e-mail to ask him how he was doing. On Friday I got a reply - he sad he decided not to go to Houston after all and that although things were pretty tough, so far there were no major complications. You can imagine my shock when I learned he was gone. Chris shone bright, like a soaring meteor. I miss him now, but I am grateful to have known him.
I was a postdoc in Chris Lab from 2008 to2010. I really appreciate Chris for giving me the chance of working with him. My background is enzymology, so I worked on the project of reassembly outcore of LPS in vitro. During this project, what gave me most impression about Chris is his sharp feeling in science. Once I had some new data on Monday morning lab meeting, he would give me some new idea either to confirm the result or go to the next step of the experiment next day. As I remembered he once mentioned during the Monday morning lab meeting that one time on the 2 or 3 AM, he suddenly got some idea for a project. At that time I know Chris is thinking of science all the time.
ReplyDeleteChris is not only a great scientist and mentor but also very nice person. Each time when I need some time off, I felt he did not even think of that for long, he always would say “sure”. And I still remember the happy hour we had in the lab when somebody was leaving or some students graduated. Also the pool party we had in his beautiful house. All these will be remembered by me forever.
I was a graduate student in Chris' lab at Duke from 1994-1999. A key reason that I chose Duke for graduate school was so that I could do research with the renowned Chris Raetz.
ReplyDeleteChris gave me freedom to explore and come up with my own ideas, while not letting me get too far off track. I am grateful for this, as well as the solid scientific foundation, opportunities, support, and kindnesses that Chris offered me during my time in his lab, and as I have progressed in my career. Oh, and we did have some fun parties!
I wish that I could tell this to Chris directly, but I appreciate the opportunity to share with you.
With warm regards to Madeline, Jacie, Lizzie, grandson, and also to the Raetz scientific family.
As posts seem to have slowed, I wanted to share some some comments I have received and appreciated.
ReplyDeleteFrom Professor Joseph Lam, Canada Research Chair in Cystic Fibrosis and Microbial Glycobiology, University of Guelph:
Dear David,
This is very sad news indeed. He is a preeminent scientist and I have the utmost respect for him. We have lost a leader and a giant in the fields of glycobiology research, lipid research, and antimicrobial research. Please convey my condolences to his family and all of his trainees and associates, past and present.
I learned about the passing of Chris Raetz a couple of days ago from my colleague Chris Whitfield, who has been a close friend of Dr. Raetz. We realized that he is gravely ill recently because Whitfield was asked by the organizer of the glyco-meeting in Vienna to give a talk at the conference to replace Dr. Raetz spot in their program.
I too have known him for more than 20 years and met him in various occasions because of our common interest in this field. I saw him about 18 months ago, when he was invited by Russell Bishop to give a seminar at McMaster University. He was looking quite chipper at the time and in remission after being diagnosed with cancer. I realized that he was almost ready to move to Colorado until he came down with cancer.
I am really sorry to hear about this sad news. We will miss him.
It was an oversight that we have not dedicated our recent mBio paper in honour of Chris Raetz. I guess we were all so wrapped up in revising the manuscript and making it fit the page limit. At this stage, it would be too late to do so because all the type-setting have been done and the paper has already appeared online as the final published form. I recently dedicated one of my papers to a colleague and long time friend of mine, Dr. Malcolm Perry of the National Research Council, for the impact of his life-long contributions to the field of microbial complex polysaccharides.
Well, I'll put a reminder on my bulletin board, and will aim to dedicate my my next paper to Dr. Raetz. I have a manuscript that is in review right now and should be back with reviewers' comments in the next few days. I will insert a footnote to dedicate it to him.
God bless,
Joe
I was a postdoc in Chris’s lab during the period of 1996 -1998. The last time I saw Chris was in September of 2009, when he came to Novartis to give a talk. After his talk a colleague pulled me aside to tell me “It is so easy to tell how significant a figure he is in the field. You were lucky to have the chance to work in his lab”. After an unease pause, and with some restless movement of her eyes, she added in a whisper “I’ve never seen anyone wear a baseball cap with suit”. I looked at her and could not help to laugh. That was Chris. That was his way of showing his pride in being a professor at Duke. Like it or not, he made a style of that combination, and he looked cute sporting it. I really love the picture of Chris posted here. The suit, the hat, and his smile - I felt his presence each time I opened this page.
ReplyDeleteI also have a few words about the Monday Morning Lab Meetings (MMLM). Interestingly, when we were in the lab, almost everyone of us complained about it. Later, after we had packed up and started working else where, we came to appreciate how much we had learned. MMLM is an efficient way to manage a lab. Chris never looked over our shoulders or demanded us to work nights or weekends; yet we did. The reason is simple: no bullshit at MMLMs. The 10 to15 minute verbal report at the MMLM’s was a results-driven weekly performance review. Shame on any of us if Chris said “I don’t know what you are talking about” or “I think we have communication problems”.
The other thing I remember about Chris was his ability to manage his time. When I applied for a green card in 2007, I e-mailed six of my professors and colleagues asking them to write me supporting reference letters. Chris responded the very next day; first before any one. During my last couple of months at Duke, Chris helped me revise my LptA paper. He gave me a date he hope to finish by and then, in the end, sent me the final revision a day early. And he routinely completed his grant proposals a month before due. Being a procrastinator myself, I am still in awe of Chris’s ability to manage his time, while under a heavy load of work and with all the responsibilities he had.
Chris was the brightest in minds, and he was a great mentor. I consider myself extremely lucky to have the chance to work in his lab. I respected him tremendously, and he will always be in my heart and memory.
I was a graduate student in Chris' lab from 2004-2008. I think the memory I appreciate most about Chris is his love of the control experiment. After joining the lab, I quickly realized that if my experiment went horribly wrong but the control verified what was concluded by previous Raetz lab experiments, then my experiment was deemed a success. I also realized that I had to prove myself to Chris. If my experimental results differed from previous Raetz lab findings, the following would happen:
ReplyDeleteMy fist set of results (that differed from previous findings) were dismissed as "fishy" (as Louis mentioned) and I was asked to repeat the experiment.
If my second set of results agreed with my first set, Chris would begin to take notice and ask senior researchers in the lab his/her opinion of whether or not he/she thinks I know what the heck I am doing.
With senior researcher backing and a third set of results in agreement with the first two, Chris began to believe my results. And what about the previous results that my results did not agree with? Well Chris would say something like: "Well, that experiment was done by a previous grad student and he/she really only did it one time." Ha, now you tell me.
Chris' skepticism was part of what made him a great scientist and a great mentor. Chris taught me the beauty of the control experiment and the value critically evaluating results. I know I would not be where I am today without his guidance, and I am blessed to have been taught by him.
I was a postdoc with Chris from 1980 to 1983 (when I got a job, yeah). I interviewed with Chris and remember walking along with him and Jeff Esko, with me being quite excited and offering numerous, and perhaps helpful, comments. They must have been impressive thoughts because Chris offered my a spot in his lab. Perhaps not based on my previous postdoc purifying gamma glutamyltranspeptidase, but because he was good friends with Bob Bell, my PhD mentor. In addition, Jeff offered me a spot in town, specifically, I inherited his apartment at the top floor of a house with where much of the space consisted of sloped ceilings. Another significant portion was the home of a very large plant, too large to move obviously, that managed to hang on for a good while. I’m not a green thumb guy.
ReplyDeleteWhile I know some details of the lipid X discovery, what sticks with me is the “famous” debt payoff by the “unknown” biochemist. Word had spread that that day’s biochemistry lecture was to be the site of a debt rehabilitation, and was not to be missed. Sitting in the back bench Chris was resplendent in the front giving his lecture being, apparently, in his wedding suit. He had a microphone attached to his lapel, which was plugged in with a long black cord, He would pause frequently to remove pieces of dust and exclaim how important the suit was when, suddenly, an unknown biochemist with a bag over her their head advanced with a crème pie. What I most remember was Chris moving around the demonstration lab bench in the front and, reaching the limit of the microphone cord, was trapped and leaning back as far away from the nascent pie as he could get and had only a single plea…”not yet, I’m not done with the lecture.”
I learned a lot from Chris, and his mentors, and appreciate all of it.